Ratings
At every ice cream ice cream place we visit, I rate the ice cream on a scale from 1-10, 1 being ok (although all ice cream is at least pretty good), and 10 being an all-time favorite. I often use fractions because, as I say, the number just comes to me. The ice cream is rated based on taste, presentation, consistency, and overall experience. Check out all of my ratings below!
Bruster’s Real Ice Cream, Glendale, AZ – 10
Fenton’s Creamery, Oakland, CA – 10
Baskin-Robbins, Scottsdale, AZ – 10
Mister Softee, Fire Island, NY – 10
Carvel, Patchogue, NY – 10
Papa Ed’s Ice Cream, Glendale, AZ – 10
Jeremiah’s Italian Ice, Chandler, AZ – 10
Mighty Moo, Youngtown, AZ – 10
Big Gay Ice Cream, Greenwich Village, NY – 10
Scookie at Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria, Scottsdale, AZ – 10
Friatto, Araucanía, Chile – 10
Lush Burger Classic Cookie Pie, Scottsdale, AZ – 10
Dessert in the Desert, Scottsdale, AZ – 10 (Lucy Guest Rating: 9 1/3)
Novel Ice Cream, Phoenix, AZ – 9 15/16
Yogurtology, Scottsdale, AZ – 9 15/16
Yogu Crem, Bahía Inglesa, Chile – 9 12/13
D’Fab, Santiago, Chile – 9 12/13
JW Marriott Pool Sundae, Phoenix, AZ – 9 10/11
Shakes and Cones, Scottsdale, AZ – 9 6/7
Las Palomas Pool Ice Cream, Puerto Peñasco, Mexico – 9 5/6
Phineas Q. Butterfats, Hollywood, CA – 9 5/6
Scooptacular, Laveen, AZ – 9 3/4
Crazy Sundae, Ojos Caburgua, Chile – 9 2/3
The City Creamery, Cave Creek, AZ – 9 2/3
Rocky Road Ice Cream Co., Sedona, AZ – 9 2/3
Handel’s, Northridge, CA – 9 1/2
Cold Stone Creamery, Phoenix, AZ – 9 1/2
The Sugar Bowl, Scottsdale, AZ – 9 1/2
Superior Dairy, Hanford, CA – 9 1/2
Han’s Homemade Ice Cream, Costa Mesa, CA – 9 1/2
Dippin Dots, Phoenix, AZ – 9 1/2
Peter Piper Pizza, Scottsdale, AZ – 9 1/2
The Creek Cookies and Cream, Cave Creek, AZ – 9 1/2
Menchies Frozen Yogurt, Scottsdale, AZ – 9 1/2
Churn, Phoenix, AZ – 9 1/2
El Toldo Azul, Santiago, Chile – 9 1/2
Organ Stop Pizza, Mesa, AZ – 9 5/12
Frozen Penguin, Scottsdale, AZ – 9
Creamistry, Scottsdale, AZ – 9
Sonic Blast, Scottsdale, AZ – 9
Shake Shack, Scottsdale, AZ – 9
Yogurtini, Scottsdale, AZ – 9
Screamery, Tuscon, AZ – 9
Carla Marla’s Ice Cream Parlor, Bellport, NY – 9
Wanderlust Creamery, Tarzana, CA – 9
Ben & Jerry’s, New York City, NY – 9
Sherald’s Frosty Freeze, Price, UT – 9
Pops Heladeria, San José, Costa Rica – 9
Coneheads, Phoenix, AZ – 9
The Gelato Spot, Phoenix, AZ – 9
Visalia Baseball Stadium, Visalia, CA – 9
Arizona Donut & Ice Cream Festival, Phoenix, AZ – 9
Piccolo’s, Scottsdale, AZ – 9
Golden Spoon, Scottsdale, AZ – 9
Pier at Davis Park, Fire Island, NY – 9
The Baked Bear, Scottsdale, AZ – 9
Kopa, Iguazu Falls, Argentina – 9
Jauense, Foz de Iguazu, Brazil – 8 9/10
Scoop and Joy Lounge, Scottsdale, AZ – 8 1/2
Rori’s Artisanal Creamery, Santa Barbara, CA – 8 1/2
Oakland Coliseum Ice Cream, Oakland, CA – 8 1/2
McMahon’s Ice Cream, Chandler, AZ – 8 1/2
Mary Coyle Ol’ Fashion Ice Cream, Phoenix, AZ – 8 1/2
The Ice Cream Cottage, Mastic, NY – 8
Sweet Republic, Scottsdale, AZ – 8
Wendy’s Frosty, Scottsdale, AZ – 8
Twix Ice Cream Bar – 7
Sweet Provisions, Scottsdale, AZ – 5